Proctor owns a 10-3 edge since the teams began their Section 7AA rivalry in 2004. The 2014 game was canceled due to weather.
| DATE | RESULT | SCORE | LOCATION | NOTES |
| 4/07/15 | W | 11-0 | Eveleth | 5 innings |
| 5/13/13 | W | 13-3 | Proctor | 5 innings |
| 5/30/12 | W | 9-0 | Proctor | Section 7AA Playoffs, 1st Round |
| 4/10/12 | W | 10-0 | Proctor | 6 innings |
| 5/20/11 | W | 7-3 | Eveleth | |
| 5/21/10 | L | 3-6 | Proctor | |
| 5/15/09 | W | 5-1 | Eveleth | |
| 5/16/08 | L | 6-12 | Proctor | |
| 5/18/07 | W | 5-3 | Eveleth | 8 innings |
| 5/19/06 | W | 15-5 | Proctor | |
| 4/12/05 | L | 3-9 | Eveleth | |
| 6/03/04 | W | 11-7 | Virginia | Section 7AA Playoffs, 1st Round |
| 5/21/04 | W | 11-1 | Proctor |
| DATE | RESULT | SCORE | LOCATION | NOTES |
| 4/26/69 | W | 11-3 | Proctor |