Ashland owns an 8-2 advantage since the teams began their Lake Superior Conference rivalry in 2007.
| DATE | RESULT | SCORE | LOCATION | NOTES |
| 5/23/15 | L | 1-8 | Proctor | |
| 4/13/15 | W | 9-3 | Ashland | |
| 5/05/14 | L | 0-5 | Proctor | |
| 5/11/13 | L | 2-7 | Ashland | |
| 4/26/12 | L | 1-2 | Proctor | 10 innings |
| 5/03/11 | W | 10-4 | Ashland | |
| 4/29/10 | L | 0-13 | Proctor | 5 innings |
| 4/23/09 | L | 5-11 | Ashland | |
| 5/09/08 | L | 5-6 | Proctor | |
| 4/26/07 | L | 7-8 | Ashland |