| 2016 | Jake Malec | 2021 Great Falls Voyagers (Ind) 2022 Great Falls Voyagers (Ind) 2023 Great Falls Voyagers (Ind) |
| 1980 | Jason Malec | 1984 Elizabethton Twins (Rk) 1985 Elizabethton Twins (Rk) 1985 Kenosha Twins (A) |
| 1944* | Gerald "Peanuts" Peterson | 1946 Duluth Dukes (C) 1947 Duluth Dukes (C) 1948 Duluth Dukes (C) |
| 1939 | Ted Downs | 1943 Duluth Dukes (E) |
| 1939 | Leonard "Willie" Mortinsen | 1943 Duluth Marine Iron (E) |
| 1933* | Finn Bakken | 1938 Duluth Dukes (D) 1943 Duluth Heralds (E) |
| 1933 | Maurice "Spike" Gorham | 1935 Brainerd Blues (D) 1936 Superior Blues (D) 1937 Des Moines Demons (A) |
*Did not graduate.
| 2016 | Jake Malec | North Dakota State |
| 1962 | Joe Lane | Minnesota |
| 1939 | Ted Downs | Wisconsin |
| 1994 | Anthony Bush | Bemidji State |
| 1992 | Derek Parendo | Minnesota Duluith |
| 1987 | Mark Slattengren | Minnesota Duluth |
| 1986 | Lee Stephenson | Minnesota Duluth |
| 1982 | Ray Miles | Minnesota Duluth |
| 1981 | Chuck Flynn | Minnesota Duluth |
| 1981 | Dan Norton | Minnesota Duluth |
| 1981 | Bill Richardson | Moorhead State |
| 1980 | Jason Malec | Minnesota Duluth |
| 1978 | Jay Nelson | Minnesota Duluth |
| 1978 | Dale Nikko | Minnesota Duluth |
| 1977 | Joe Gaboury | Minnesota Duluth |
| 1972 | Terry Egerdahl | Minnesota Duluth |
| 1972 | Jim Masterson | Minnesota Duluth |
| 2018 | Bryce Huffman | St. Scholastica |
| 2012 | Jake Lewis | Wisconsin-Superior |
| 2011 | Alex Oachs | St. Scholastica |
| 2005 | Kyle Wojtysiak | St. Scholastica |
| 2003 | Nick Podgornik | Wisconsin-Superior |
| 2000 | Erik Esala | Wisconsin-Superior |
| 2000 | Luke Wargin | Wisconsin-Superior |
| 1996 | Ben Carlson | Wisconsin-Superior |
| 1994 | Anthony Bush | Wisconsin-Superior |
| 1994 | Tony Flick | St. Scholastica |
| 1994 | Josh Schubitzke | Wisconsin-Superior |
| 1994 | Chris Watkins | Hamline |
| 1993 | Mike Davis | Wisconsin-Superior |
| 1993 | Scott McLeod | St. Scholastica |
| 1991 | Chris Nylund | Hamline |
| 1990 | Brian Peterson | Springfield (Mass.) |
| 1981 | Scott Pionk | Wisconsin-Superior |
| 1949 | Ron Main | Augsburg |
| 2019 | Zach Gunderson | Dakota County Tech |
| 2019 | Austin Parrott | Mesabi Range |
| 2014 | Evan Scherber | Mesabi Range |
| 2013 | Matt Dolsen | Fond du Lac |
| 2013 | Jack Nikko | Vermilion |
| 2012 | Ryan McCarthy | Mesabi Range |
| 2012 | Jesse Scanlon | Mesabi Range |
| 2011 | Pat Everson | Mesabi Range |
| 2011 | Nick Nylund | Mesabi Range |
| 2011 | Justin Scanlon | Mesabi Range |
| 2010 | Jesse Gilberg | Fond du Lac |
| 2009 | Tim Nylund | Hibbing |
| 2006 | Blake Reinke | Mesabi Range |
| 2004 | Jesse Frick | Hibbing |
| 2004 | Dustin Wiita | Hibbing |
| 2000 | Luke Wargin | Mesabi Range |
| 1988 | Mike Robertson | Hibbing |
| 1983 | Rick Giese | Hibbing |
| 1981 | Nik Peterson | Golden Valley Lutheran |
| 1980 | Jason Malec | Hibbing |
| 2018 | Bryce Huffman | St. Scholastica | 2021 All-UMAC First Team |
| 2016 | Jake Malec | North Dakota State | 2021 Team Captain 2021 SL Player of the Week (March 8) 2021 All-SL Academic 2021 All-SL Tournament 2021 SL Tournament MVP 2021 All-SL First Team 2020 Team Captain 2020 SL Academic Honor Roll 2020 SL Commissioner's List of Academic Excellence 2019 SL Academic Honor Roll 2019 SL Commissioner's List of Academic Excellence 2018 SL Academic Honor Roll 2017 SL Academic Honor Roll |
| 2012 | Jake Lewis | Wisconsin-Superior | 2016 Team Pitcher of the Year 2016 All-UMAC Honorable Mention 2013 All-WIAC Academic Honor Roll |
| 2005 | Kyle Wojtysiak | St. Scholastica | 2009 Team Captain 2009 All-UMAC First Team 2009 Team Gold Glove 2008 All-UMAC Honorable Mention 2008 All-UMAC Academic 2008 Team Gold Glove |
| 1994 | Anthony Bush | Wisconsin-Superior | 1999 Team Captain 1999 Team Most Inspirational Player |
| 1993 | Mike Davis | Wisconsin-Superior | 1997 All-WIAC Honorable Mention 1994 All-WIAC Honorable Mention |
| 1993 | Scott McLeod | St. Scholastica | 1997 All-UMAC First Team 1997 Midwest All-Region |
| 1991 | Chris Nylund | Hamline | 1995 All-MIAC Honorable Mention 1995 All-MIAC Academic |
| 1987 | Mark Slattengren | Minnesota Duluth | 1992 Team Captain 1992 Team MVP 1989 Team Rookie of the Year |
| 1982 | Ray Miles | Minnesota Duluth | 1986 All-NIC First Team 1983 Team Rookie of the Year |
| 1981 | Chuck Flynn | Minnesota Duluth | 1982 Team Rookie of the Year |
| 1980 | Jason Malec | Minnesota Duluth Hibbing CC |
1984 All-NIC First Team 1984 Team MVP 1983 All-NIC First Team 1981 Northeast Division Batting Champion |
| 1979 | Scott Pionk | Wisconsin-Superior | 1985 All-WIAC Honorable Mention 1984 All-WIAC First Team 1983 All-WIAC Honorable Mention |
| 1972 | Terry Egerdahl | Minnesota Duluth | 1976 Team Captain 1976 Team MVP 1976 All-MIAC First Team 1975 Team Captain 1975 Team MVP 1974 Team MVP 1974 All-MIAC First Team |