Proctor owns a 6-4 edge in the last 10 games against Hermantown.
| DATE | RESULT | SCORE | LOCATION | NOTES |
| 5/26/15 | W | 10-9 | Ely | Section 7AA Playoffs 2nd Round, 8 innngs |
| 4/10/15 | W | 7-5 | Hermantown | |
| 5/15/14 | L | 0-2 | Proctor | |
| 5/16/13 | L | 3-5 | Proctor | |
| 6/05/12 | W | 9-0 | Hermantown | Section 7AA Playoffs Semifinals |
| 5/17/12 | W | 7-5 | Hermantown | |
| 4/13/12 | L | 3-4 | Proctor | |
| 6/09/11 | W | 4-3 | Duluth (Wade) | Section 7AA Playoffs Championship (Game 2) |
| 6/09/11 | W | 6-3 | Duluth (Wade) | Section 7AA Playoffs Championship (Game 1) |
| 6/02/11 | L | 2-10 | Proctor | Section 7AA Playoffs Quarterfinals |
| 5/19/11 | W | 8-3 | Proctor | |
| 5/20/10 | W | 17-4 | Hermantown | |
| 5/27/09 | L | 1-5 | Hermantown | Section 7AA Playoffs 1st Round |
| 5/14/09 | L | 5-6 | Proctor | |
| 5/15/08 | L | 3-10 | Hermantown | |
| 5/17/07 | L | 0-2 | Proctor | |
| 5/18/06 | L | 2-3 | Hermantown | |
| 5/24/05 | L | 0-6 | Proctor | |
| 6/03/04 | L | 2-5 | Hinckley | Section 7AA Playoffs 2nd Round |
| 5/20/04 | L | 1-10 | Hermantown | |
| 5/15/03 | L | 3-13 | Proctor | |
| 5/14/02 | L | 4-14 | Hermantown | |
| 5/16/01 | L | 6-7 | Proctor | |
| 5/02/00 | W | 9-5 | Proctor | |
| 5/06/99 | W | 3-1 | Hermantown | |
| 5/07/98 | L | 1-8 | Proctor | |
| 5/08/97 | L | 1-8 | Hermantown | |
| 5/09/96 | L | 6-9 | Proctor | |
| 5/16/95 | L | 2-6 | Proctor | |
| 5/17/94 | L | 0-3 | Hermantown | |
| 5/25/93 | L | 4-10 | Proctor | |
| 5/09/92 | W | 10-3 | Hermantown | |
| 5/14/91 | L | 4-10 | Proctor | |
| 5/15/90 | L | 5-6 | Hermantown | |
| 5/16/89 | W | 7-6 | Proctor | |
| 5/17/88 | L | 2-4 | Hermantown | |
| 5/05/87 | W | 7-1 | Hermantown | |
| 5/06/86 | W | 3-2 | Proctor | |
| 5/17/85 | W | 16-2 | Hermantown | |
| 4/18/84 | W | 6-2 | Proctor | |
| 5/16/83 | L | 4-5 | Hermantown | |
| 5/26/82 | L | 7-8 | Proctor | |
| 4/20/81 | W | 13-4 | Hermantown | |
| 4/18/80 | W | 10-0 | Cloquet | |
| 5/12/79 | W | 6-3 | Hermantown | |
| 4/27/78 | W | 3-0 | Hermantown | |
| 4/26/77 | W | 3-2 | Proctor | |
| 4/20/76 | L | 3-4 | Hermantown | |
| 5/19/75 | L | 1-8 | ||
| /74 | L | |||
| 5/17/73 | L | 4-15 | Proctor | |
| 5/18/72 | W | 13-2 | Hermantown | |
| 5/26/71 | W | 2-1 | Duluth (Wade) | District 26 Tournament 1st Round |
| 5/13/71 | W | 7-4 | ||
| 5/14/70 | W | 8-5 | ||
| 5/13/69 | L | 1-4 | 11 innings | |
| 5/09/68 | W | 7-3 | Proctor | |
| 5/20/54 | W | 3-1 | Proctor | |
| 7/20/49 | W | 5-4 | Hermantown | |
| 6/28/49 | T | 7-7 | Proctor | |
| 7/14/48 | W | 6-5 | Hermantown |