Superior holds a 6-4 edge in the last 10 games of the Lake Superior Conference series.
| DATE | RESULT | SCORE | LOCATION | NOTES |
| 5/05/15 | L | 2-4 | Superior | |
| 4/25/15 | L | 2-5 | Superior | Superior Tournament |
| 5/17/14 | W | 9-8 | Hibbing | Hibbing Tournament |
| 5/06/14 | L | 3-6 | Proctor | |
| 5/07/13 | L | 4-5 | Superior | |
| 5/19/12 | L | 9-15 | Hibbing | Hibbing Tournament |
| 5/08/12 | W | 8-0 | Proctor | |
| 5/10/11 | W | 2-1 | Superior | 11 innings |
| 5/11/10 | W | 11-1 | Proctor | 6 innings |
| 5/11/09 | L | 2-3 | Superior | |
| 5/06/08 | L | 6-12 | Proctor | |
| 5/08/07 | L | 3-10 | Superior | |
| 5/09/06 | W | 8-4 | Proctor | |
| 5/10/05 | L | 2-6 | Superior | |
| 5/11/04 | L | 1-11 | Proctor | 6 innings |
| 5/06/03 | L | 0-16 | Superior | 5 innings |
| 5/02/02 | L | 0-18 | Proctor | 5 innings |
| 5/03/01 | L | 3-6 | Superior | |
| 4/25/00 | L | 3-4 | Superior | |
| 4/27/99 | L | 3-4 | Proctor | |
| 4/28/98 | L | 2-12 | Superior | 6 innings |
| 4/29/97 | W | 7-5 | Proctor | |
| 4/30/96 | L | 1-6 | Superior | |
| 5/05/95 | W | 7-3 | Superior | |
| 5/07/94 | L | 6-16 | Proctor | |
| 5/13/93 | W | 13-5 | Superior | |
| 5/01/92 | L | 3-11 | Proctor | |
| 4/18/91 | L | 1-9 | Superior | Coach LeBlanc's first game |
| 4/19/90 | W | 4-3 | Proctor | |
| 4/20/89 | W | 3-2 | Superior | |
| 4/21/88 | L | 1-11 | Superior | |
| 4/23/87 | L | 5-12 | Proctor | |
| 5/16/86 | L | 12-14 | Superior | |
| 5/17/85 | L | 1-11 | Superior | 5 innings |
| 5/15/84 | L | 4-13 | Proctor | |
| 5/17/83 | W | 8-6 | Superior | |
| 5/19/82 | L | 1-4 | Proctor | |
| 5/13/81 | W | 3-1 | Superior | |
| 5/14/80 | L | 1-5 | Duluth (Wade) | |
| 5/15/79 | W | 7-3 | Superior | |
| 5/13/78 | L | 4-9 | Superior | |
| 5/14/77 | L | 1-11 | Superior | 6 innings |
| 4/21/76 | L | 3-4 | Proctor | |
| 4/23/73 | L | 4-8 | ||
| 5/05/72 | L | 0-6 | Lake Nebagamon | 5 innings (rain) |
| 4/16/66 | L | 1-3 | Superior | SSHS's first game |